Vintage Star PWEs

One of the things that’s starting to happen over on Card Twitter is that guys will celebrate a player’s birthday* by showing off a page or two worth of his cards of not his complete Topps run. This is always cool to see but also frequently serves to remind me how my focus on Giants has left me with a collection that has basically none of the memorable players from the 60s and 70s.

*or as has been happening a depressing amount of the time recently, his passing.

Last week I made a comment about this regarding Dick Allen and Matthew Castelhano (@Mattypabst) immediately suggested that this needed to be rectified. Matthew is another collector who spends a lot of his time with pre-war cards of all sorts and we’ve compared notes and been bad influences on each other in terms of pointing out cool sets that are worth lusting after. He’s also a member of the group of us which are passively collecting cards of every player who broke a team’s colorline.

A couple days ago the envelope showed up and inside was this 1976 Topps Dick Allen card. Allen is in the last years of his career here and has returned to the Phillies after three years of being an All Star in Chicago. I’d still like to get a card of him from the 1960s but it’s great to have one card of  a player who’s on the shortlist of players who are the larges absences from the Hall of Fame.

Matthew packed the Allen with three other cards including a couple more which also represent firsts in my binder. I have Yastrzemskis from 1978 and 1983 but none from his true peak years. This 1968 Topps Game card doesn’t get more peak as it comes after his MVP season. Winning the Triple Crown and MVP in 1967 put Yaz on the same level as Mantle and Aaron in this game, only trailing Clemente, Killebrew, Frank Robinson, and Mays.

Boog Powell is another star who I have no cards of. This 1970 comes from his MVP season and features a very 1970 photo taken a Yankee stadium with the random players in the background. It’s always nice to see the frieze though. I was also unaware that Boog’s full name is actually John Wesley Powell. That’s quite a dude to be named after.

Matthew apologized for the condition of the Yaz and Boog cards but they’re as good, if not better than the kind of cards I buy.

The last card in the envelope was a 2019 Heritage Candy Lid of Buster Posey. I love getting cards like this in the mail since while I would never buy them. I do very much enjoy putting them in the binder.

The same day Matthew’s envelope came I also received one from Tim Jenkins. The big item inside was a postcard of Steve Whitaker. I think Tim’s printing these himself and a lot of us have been getting them. I got a Whitake postcard because he played 16 games for the Giants in 1970 (he also  got a 1970 Topps card)

Also in the envelope were a pair of cards including my first vintage Bob Gibson—another player I had mentioned online about not having any vintage of. This isn’t a 1960s card from when he was dominating everyone but it’s a very nice looking card with the blue border contrasting nicely with the red jacket while both the jersey design and jacket design are visible. There’s an added bonus here in that an under-construction Candlestick is visible in the background.

The 1974 checklist meanwhile is in really good shape. I have this already but I’m pretty sure mine is marked and beat up since I refuse to spend more money for an unmarked checklist.

Very cool guys and thanks for helping me get a more representative binder.